It took me three weeks, but I finally read War Journal. Let me be clear: I enjoyed this comic. The artwork is top notch, and Punisher’s mercilessness is represented in fantastic detail.
I don’t, however, know how this adds to the Civil War story. Other than Marvel’s wanting to include all heroes in the series, I don’t see Punisher’s presence as necessary, in the same way that other’s are. He basically shows up to kill a couple people, one semi-pro super villain, and frustrate Captain America’s attempts to welcome him to his team. The only interesting interaction between the two main characters is the flashback scene (where it is revealed that Frank Castle served as a marine and was trained by Captain America), and the scene where Captain America disciplines the Punisher, who refuses to fight back.
Don’t get me wrong, the scenes are action charged and Frank Castle’s mercenary for a higher power bit has its high points as well, but overall, this book was less than impressive. It jumps around a lot; at one point you’re in the present with Castle, at another you’re in the apartment of Stuart Clarke-a nerdy robot manufacturer with superhero delusions of grandeur-not sure where or when the interactions are supposed to be taking place. Then, you flashback to Castle’s past, only to to find him a young marine in the process of being trained by Captain America himself… 
The entire final issue takes place at the wake for Stiltman, the semi-pro super villain killed by Frank castle in the first issue, and features very little of the Punisher at all. The focus of the issue is the criminals and villains who have gathered at a bar to drink to the memory of the fallen Stiltman. The biggest names in the crowd are Dr. Doom and the Rhino, but others present are: the original prowler, the eel, the always misunderstood gibbon, and the widow princess python. For the majority of the story, these bad guys and gals drink, argue, push and shove, as the mourn the loss of their comrade. As they get drunker, they start to turn on one another (at one point the original prowler accuses another of stealing his costume/identity). Before long, its just another drunken bar brawl featuring wanted criminals and super villains, that comes to a grinding halt when Spiderman walks in…
This is where it gets really weird. Spiderman swings by the bar to pay his respects to the departed, and I have to guess that this is the only reason that the crowd doesn’t attack him. We all know that spidey’s not to be f’d with, but still…all those bad guys and not one of ‘em even wants to pick a fight with an all-alone Spiderman, while drunk?!? I find that hard to believe. Spidey walks in, talks shit, and then leaves . It is only later that we realize that the whole scene is a set up, and that the Punisher was the bartender, serving up poisoned drinks to the crowd the whole time. He exits the building, followed by explosions, and we see that all those bad guys have been punished!!!!
That’s where this book ends. I’m not sure if there are others yet, but if there are, hopefully they will fill in what is right now a very obscure and incomplete part of the Civil War story line. Like I said, I enjoyed the comic…I’m just not sure how it fits in.
Rufus Spidermang


















